Renewable Heating Incentive (RHI) Scandal
Posted By: December 13, 2016
Foster’s tone has changed
Irish News (Belfast). Editorial. Tuesday, December 13, 2016
Arlene Foster, just back from China and straight into a full-scale crisis, has firmly defended her handling of the renewable heating scandal.
The first minister had little option but to come out fighting. This fiasco not only overshadowed her high-profile trade mission to China but has shaken confidence in the competence of government, in particular, a department she presided over as minister.
Questions about the Renewable Heating Incentive (RHI) are now piling up, and the first minister will realize she has to act, not just to restore public confidence but to head off any suggestion that DUP ministers – herself included – failed to manage the department of enterprise (Deti) properly.
It was noticeable that Mrs. Foster’s tone in interviews yesterday was less dismissive than in her initial comments on this issue.
She expressed regret at the way the scheme was implemented, acknowledged its flaws, but did not go as far as apologizing for the debacle.
Nor did she say sorry to the whistleblower who did her level best to alert officials to the looming disaster only to be ignored.
What Mrs. Foster did promise was an inspection program, with around 2,000 beneficiaries of the scheme checked to ensure there is no abuse of public money.
It is not clear what this will cost or what is likely to come out of it. The problem with RHI is that businesses can legitimately burn fuel they don’t need and receive payment from the government.
It has also emerged that a former special adviser to the First Minister, Stephen Brimstone, is a claimant of RHI while the brother of a current special adviser, Andrew Crawford, is also benefiting from the scheme.
As the party in control of this initiative, the DUP needs to reveal who else within its ranks or with links to representatives and advisors, successfully applied for the renewable heat incentive.
Now is the time for absolute transparency and a recognition that legitimate concerns must be addressed.
***
Foster: I won’t quit over £400m cash-for-ash fiasco
Michael Mc Hugh. Irish News (Belfast). Tuesday, December 13, 2016
CHALLENGE: First Minister Arlene Foster PICTURE: Niall Carson/PA First Minister Arlene Foster has said she will not resign over a failed renewable heating scheme in Northern Ireland. |
The overspending project was designed to encourage businesses to switch from burning fossil fuels to wood biomass heating but has left taxpayers with a bill critics claim could reach £400 million. The DUP leader said she passed on whistleblower concerns raised with her in 2014 to the civil service. |
She is also seeking to publish details of all those who benefited. “I will not be resigning. It is political opponents and opponents elsewhere who will always take the opportunity to put out the usual she should resign remark,” she said. “I take the view that a mark of a politician is not made when times are good but when you are faced with challenges. .I intend to face this challenge and to deal with the issues in front of me and to bring about cost reduction for the scheme.” The Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI) paid out more than the fuel cost, meaning users could earn more the more they burned, leading to claims of an |
“cash-for-ash” scam of heating buildings unnecessarily. For a spell, Mrs. Foster was in charge as enterprise, trade and investment minister. Mrs. Foster said officials are to write to those who receive payments asking if their names can be disclosed, as required under data protection rules. “What is important for us is that we bring forward proposals to the assembly in early January to make sure that we reduce the potential cost of the scheme to make sure that it does not cost the sort of money that has been talked about,” she said. Mrs. Foster said a whistleblower sent correspondence to her which she passed to officials to deal with. “That is the accepted way that you deal with these issues,” she said. “If someone comes to you about a matter concerning the department you then give it to officials to deal with and that is exactly what I did.” “I regret, of course, that it was not dealt with within the appropriate fashion.” She said normally such issues were brought back to the minister after being |
dealt with and they did not happen in this case. “I do regret that that is the case.” She said most of those who benefited were legitimate businesses which applied into a scheme which had a good policy aim – to cut carbon emissions. |
“It is entirely wrong to smear all of those people in a way that some [news] outlets have been trying to do.” She said the north needed its own scheme because more people were moving from oil to renewables than in the rest of the UK, where gas predominates. “Unfortunately, they got it wrong and the design of the scheme was wrong,” Mrs. Foster said. She said the advice given to her by senior officials did not reflect adequate |
checks and balances. “None of the alarm bells were ringing before I left the department because at that time we had an underspend in relation to the RHI and it was only later that the overspend was projected and that is when alarm bells started to ring,” she said. “If they had listened to the whistleblower at that particular time then we would have been able to deal with the issue at an earlier stage.” Mrs. Foster said there was no bar on members of the DUP or anyone else applying to the scheme. “Most people who applied into the scheme did so in a legitimate fashion. We want to find those people who set out to abuse the scheme, that is the key for me and for the department.” Ulster Unionist leader Mike Nesbitt said: “Mrs. Foster remains in denial. Today’s interviews were all about blaming everyone but herself. “The fact remains she presided over a series of policy choices which have created a £400 million debt that is her legacy to the people of Northern Ireland.” |
Foster ‘in denial’ over scandal John Manley and John Monaghan. Irish News (Belfast). Tuesday, December 13, 2016 |
FIRST Minister Arlene Foster was accused of being in denial last night amid further revelations about the Renewable Heat Incentive scandal. The DUP leader said she would not resign over failings in the green energy scheme which could cost the public purse as much as £400 million over the next two decades. |
She insisted she would “deal with the issues” caused by a failure to cap the money businesses could claim when the scheme was created during her time as head of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Investment. Mrs. Foster also defended her handling of a whistleblower’s concerns and said all claimants would be inspected, although the cost and time scale of such a review is unclear. However, opposition parties were scathing of the comments. Ulster Unionist leader Mike Nesbitt accused Mrs. Foster of “blaming everyone but herself,” while SDLP leader Colum Eastwood claimed a failure to take |
responsibility meant her position is “rapidly becoming untenable.” Mrs. Foster also revealed yesterday that former DUP special adviser Stephen Brimstone was an RHI claimant, although she said this was not connected to his departure from his role last month. The DUP did not respond to requests for comment from The Irish News regarding when and on what basis Mr. Brimstone applied to the scheme. The first minister, meanwhile, said she was unaware that a brother of Andrew Crawford, who was her special adviser at the Department of Enterprise, had been a claimant. Mr. Eastwood said he was calling for the public accounts committee to “convene an urgent meeting which compels Arlene Foster to answer all relevant questions.” |